ISSN: 1837-9664Journal of Cancer
Global reach, higher impact
J Cancer 2019; 10(26):6491-6501. doi:10.7150/jca.34891 This issue Cite
Research Paper
Research on Current Curative Expenditure among Lung Cancer Patients Based on the “System of Health Accounts 2011”: Insights into Influencing Factors
Shuang Zang1, Huan Zhan3, Liangrong Zhou3 
, Xin Wang2
1. School of Nursing, China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning;
2. College of the Humanities and Social Sciences, China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning;
3. School of Humanities and Management, Hunan University of Chinese Medicine, Changsha, Hunan.
Abstract
Purpose: To investigate the total current curative expenditure (CCE) of lung cancer in Hunan Province, China under the framework of the System of Health Accounts 2011 (SHA 2011) and explore the effect of insurance status, surgery and length of stay on the hospitalization expenses of patients with lung cancer.
Methods: Through multistage stratified cluster random sampling, a total of 46,214 patients with lung cancer were enrolled from 1,072 medical institutions in Hunan Province in 2016. Under the SHA 2011 framework, the lung cancer CCE was analyzed. The relationships between hospitalization expenditure and the following factors (surgery, type of hospital, insurance status, length of stay, institution level, age and sex) were analyzed using Spearman's correlation analyses, and how these factors influenced hospital expenditure was explored through multiple stepwise regression analysis and structural equation modelling.
Results: The CCE for lung cancer patients was 8063.75 million CNY. In total, 96.03% of the CCE for lung cancer occurred in hospitals and 58.88% of the expenditure flowed to general hospitals. The highest expenditures were incurred in the group aged 55-74 y, which accounted for 61.58% of the CCE. Drugs accounted for the greatest share expenditure to lung cancer patients at 34.31% of the CCE. Surgery, insurance status, institution level, sex and hospital type explained 57.5% of the variance in hospital expenses. The hospitalization expenses were related to surgery, insurance status, institution level and sex (rs = 0.033-0.688, p < 0.001). Surgery, insurance status and length of stay had direct effects on hospitalization expenses. Length of stay mediated the relationship between surgery and hospitalization expenses for lung cancer patients. Surgery mediated the relationship between insurance status and hospitalization expenses. All of these variables can explain 45% of the variance in hospitalization expenses.
Conclusions: The CCE of lung cancer is extremely high. The problems related to treatment efficiency and equity are serious for lung cancer patients in China. It is essential to expand health insurance coverage and reduce the curative expenditure of lung cancer.
Keywords: lung cancer, current curative expenditure, System of Health Accounts 2011
Introduction
Lung cancer is the most common malignant tumor in the world and the leading cause of cancer death. It is estimated that 2.1 million new cases of lung cancer and 1.8 million deaths from lung cancer have been reported in China, accounting for 37.0% of all new cancer cases and 39.2% of all cancer-related deaths [1]. Moreover, lung cancer is the most costly type of malignant tumor [2]. Once diagnosed, patients need to undergo intensive medical treatment and aggressive care, which leads to substantial increases in curative expenditure. More accurate diagnostic techniques and treatments have been developed and applied in the clinical practice of managing lung cancer [3,4]. Although novel and advanced cancer therapeutic treatments have improved the life expectancy and clinical outcomes, these treatments consequently lead to a rising amount of expenditure for lung cancer patients [5]. In China, the per capita medical expenditure for lung cancer patients has climbed from 40,508 CNY in 2005 to 66,020 CNY in 2014 [6]. The high expenditure for lung cancer may create great challenges for government, families and patients.
Studies on lung cancer expenditure and its influencing factors have been carried out globally. The data for the studies on lung cancer expenditure mainly came from the Medicare database [7] and medical institution records [8]. As most of the research data were roughly estimated from medical records, the expenditures, such as fixed assets that were not used on patients, were still included in the real expenditures on health care. The actual final consumption of goods and services purchased on behalf of the individuals cannot be calculated clearly. For researchers to accurately account for the curative expenditure of lung cancer, there is a pressing need to establish an expenditure account framework that both increases the accuracy of the health accounts and enables broader comparability across countries. In recent years, with significant gains in economic strength and financial revenue, the state financial allocation used for public health has jumped annually. However, there is still a significant gap between the health services provided and public demand, and the problem of “high costs to receive treatment” is still grim [9]. How serious is the situation? What are the monetary flows for expenditure on lung cancer? What are the major influencing factors of current care expenditure according to the beneficiary characteristics? All of these questions can be answered under the System of Health Accounts 2011 (SHA 2011) framework.
SHA 2011 is a standard framework that can help ensure the best quality of patients' expenditure information by institutionalizing deals for data collection, embedding the data in the information system, enforcing data production, and promoting data use. The SHA 2011 framework is now considered the global standard for the construction of national health accounts and has been adopted by all member countries of the European Union, nearly all member countries of the Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development and many additional countries [10]. Under the SHA 2011 framework, “current expenditure on health care” and “gross capital formation in health care” have been separated. The SHA 2011 framework abandons the expression of total health expenditure, although it recommends the usage of current health expenditure, which refers to the final consumption of health care goods and services by the government, nonprofit institutions and households, excluding the expenditure of fixed assets [11]. Therefore, we can track medical expenditures accurately. The direct costs of treating cancer include doctor visits, laboratory tests, imaging tests, radiation treatments, hospital stays, drug costs, etc. [12]. For cancer patients, the insurance premium levels [13], hospital level [14], length of stay [15] and surgery [16] all affect medical expenses.
Therefore, it is crucial to gain a population-level view of the expenditures for lung cancer from the perspective of sociodemographic characteristics and the distribution of treatment cost characteristics for health care decision-making. Considering the aforementioned literature, both surgery and length of stay have demonstrated an association with hospitalization expenses in lung cancer patients. However, there is limited information to explain the association between the other contributing factors and hospitalization expense in lung cancer patients. Thus, we aimed to investigate the mediating effect of surgery and length of stay on the association between these variables and hospitalization expense among lung cancer patients. We hypothesized that surgery would be associated with a high risk of hospitalization expense through an extended length of stay in the hospital. Moreover, better insurance status would be associated with a high risk of hospitalization expense through active treatment (e.g., surgery).
Currently, China is reforming its national health strategy and health care system. Policies and interventions for a more equitable health system are being implemented in this period [17]. An assessment and describing traits of the cost of treatment in China is a necessary first step in achieving this procedure. Therefore, analyzing the influencing factors of the current curative expenditure (CCE) in patients with lung cancer is essential. The data calculated based on the SHA 2011 framework may help determine the decisions linked to the allocation of resources, estimate the monetary flows related to curative care expenditure, analyze the probable factors that influence the CCE, protect the rights of patients and achieve the universal health coverage strategy that was proposed by the WHO.
Methods
Data sources
The prevalence of lung cancer in Hunan Province is similar to that in other provinces of China [18]. This population-based study selected the patients in Hunan Province as a sample population, and the macrodata and demographic data were derived from work documents at the national and provincial level. The health expenditure was extracted from the Hunan Health Statistical Yearbook (2016), Hunan Health Financial Yearbook (2016), Hunan Health Report (2016), medical institution records and public health institution records.
Quality control and data management
The process of gathering data was classified and coded according to the International Classification of Disease, the 10th revision (ICD-10). The records of lung cancer patients were coded as C34 in the ICD-10. The data extraction, audits, cleaning and calculations were maintained by implementing the basic accounting guidelines of the SHA 2011 framework [19] and a series of training courses. The staff involved in the data cleaning procedures were trained by the National Health Commission of China and evaluated through an examination. All data were entered electronically into a data terminal that was directly connected with Stata 10.0 (Stata Corporation, College Station, TX, USA).
Study sample
Multistage stratified probability-proportional-to-size random sampling method was used to ensure that there was a representative sample. The sampling proportion was 1/3 for each stratum. Randomization was achieved through lottery-style drawings (prefecture-level cities), or a computer program (selection of streets, communities and towns). A stepwise approach was used for the whole sample extraction process, with several stages described below. The first stage was to select sample cities from Hunan Province based on a comprehensive consideration of geographical location, levels of economic development, the state of medical care and the health information management system. Thus, the 5 cities of Changsha, Yueyang, Zhuzhou, Yongzhou and Hengyang were selected. In the second stage, one district and three counties (county-level cities) were randomly selected as prefecture-level cities. Within the selected districts and counties, 5-8 streets, communities and towns were randomly selected, and 2-6 villages were randomly selected from each township as sample units. After determining the sample area and sample size, the third stage was to randomly classify the samples according to the type of medical institution and the administrative level of the health care institutions and professional public health institutions. A total of 1,072 medical institutions with 71 hospitals, 27 public health institutions, 131 community health service centers or township hospitals, 678 village clinics and 165 clinics were enrolled. The basic information was collected from the information system of the institute (Outpatient and inpatient care data were enrolled), including age, sex, disease, expense, date of hospital visit, length of stay and financing scheme.
The quality of the submitted data was checked and evaluated by using a tool to sort the cases and identify the missing and/or unexpected values, outliers and suspected errors. Then, the incomplete data were confirmed in the original health institution to ensure that they were correct. Finally, 2011 items that could not be amended were abandoned. A total of 46,214 valid items for lung cancer from January 1 to December 31, 2016 were collected. The data included the new lung cancer patients in 2016 and the patients diagnosed before 2016 but still treated in 2016. A standardized basic database was established.
Descriptive statistics of the CCE for lung cancer based on the SHA 2011 framework
Medical service expenditure, government subsidies, and basic expenditure subsidies were included in the costs of lung cancer. These data were from Hunan Health Statistical Yearbook (2016), Hunan Health Financial Yearbook (2016), and Hunan Health Report (2016). The concrete calculation method was previously published and can be seen in the reference article [11].
Analyses of influencing factors of hospitalization curative care expenditure for lung cancer patients
A total of 9,008 items of inpatient data was extracted from the whole 46,214 valid items of lung cancer. Spearman's Rank-Correlation test was performed to analyze the correlations between hospitalization expenses, surgery, length of stay, insurance status, institution level, sex and age. The hospitalization expenditure was not normally distributed, and the data were normally distributed after a logarithmic transition. Multiple stepwise regression analyses were used. A path analysis was performed by structural equation modeling to test the significance of the associations and to identify the direct and indirect effects of the variables.
The statistical software SPSS 21.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) and AMOS 20.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) were used for the analyses. The significance for all statistical tests was indicated by a two-tailed p-value of 0.05.
Results
CCE situation
Based on the SHA 2011 framework, the CCE for lung cancer was 8063.75 million CNY (1 USD ≈ 6.64 RMB, 2014), which accounted for 0.74% of the total CCE in Hunan Province. Most of the CCE for lung cancer patients was in hospitals (general hospitals, special hospitals and traditional Chinese medicine hospitals), and the expenditure was 7743.52 million CNY, which accounted for 96.03% of the total CCE of lung cancer patients. This was followed by public health institutions, with an expenditure of 319.69 million CNY that accounted for 3.96% of the total CCE of lung cancer patients, and basic medical institutions, with an expenditure of 0.48 million CNY that accounted for 0.01% of the total CCE of lung cancer patients. Overall, the CCE of lung cancer patients was mostly distributed in hospitals instead of in other medical institutions.
The financing scheme in Hunan Province was divided into the following three types: public financing scheme, voluntary financing scheme and family health expenditures (out-of-pocket payments (OOPs)). The OOPs for lung cancer patients were 2741.78 million CNY, which accounted for 34.00% of the total CCE of lung cancer patients. The three financing schemes were all mainly allocated towards inpatients (Table 1). In different types of hospitals, the financing scheme had variable distributions. The lung cancer CCE flowed 4747.87 million CNY to general hospitals, which accounted for 58.88% of the total CCE; traditional Chinese medicine hospitals received 2035.79 million CNY, which accounted for 25.25% of the total CCE; and special hospitals received 959.87 million CNY, which accounted for 11.90% of the total CCE (Figure 1).
Allocation of the financing scheme for inpatients and outpatients (million CNY)
| Service function | Public financing scheme | Voluntary financing scheme | OOPs | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Social health insurance | Government financing scheme | Nonprofit organization financing | Enterprise financing plan | Family health expenditure | |
| Outpatient | 124.07 | 52.00 | 0.00 | 2.95 | 586.61 |
| Inpatient | 4475.67 | 580.69 | 30.50 | 56.05 | 2155.17 |
Variations in the CCE of lung cancer patients existed not only across types of hospitals but also across medical institution levels. The CCE of lung cancer patients flowed 2696.14 million CNY to provincial medical institutions, which accounted for 33.44% of the total CCE; 2605.25 million CNY to municipal medical institutions, which accounted for 32.31% of the total CCE; 2442.13 million CNY to district and county medical institutions, which accounted for 30.29% of the total CCE.
Flow of the CCE in different health institutions demonstrated by the Sankey diagram (CNY).
Situations that led to outpatient and inpatient expenses and the proportion of expenditure for each hospitalization expense item.
Proportion of expenditure items by hospital level.
Composition of the CCE among lung cancer patients
In general, the outpatient and inpatient CCE accounted for 9.49% and 90.51% of the CCE, respectively. That is, the inpatient expenditure was nearly 9.5 times greater than the outpatient expenditure. In addition, for lung cancer patients in hospitals, drugs, tests and surgery were the major aspects of the CCE (Figure 2). Figure 3 clearly showed that the aspects of induced CCE among lung cancer patients were dramatically different in different hospital levels. For example, the constituent ratio of drug costs was lower in provincial hospitals (28.40%) than in district and county hospitals (48.57%). Analyzing the CCE by age reveals that a significant portion of the expenditure occurred in patients aged 55-74 y, accounting for nearly 61.58% of the CCE (Figure 4). Thus, the medical expenses of elderly lung cancer patients were responsible for the increase in CCE.
Factors correlated with hospitalization expenditures
A correlation analysis was conducted to find the intercorrelations among study variables. The results of Spearman's rank correlations were shown in Table 2. In particular, the hospitalization expenses correlated significantly and positively with surgery (rs = 0.481, p < 0.001), length of stay (rs = 0.668, p < 0.001), insurance status (rs = 0.325, p < 0.001), institution level (rs = 0.585, p < 0.001) and sex (rs = 0.033, p < 0.001). The hospitalization expenses were negatively correlated with age (rs = -0.041, p < 0.001). Age was also negatively correlated with both insurance status and institution level (rs = -0.073 and -0.085, respectively, p < 0.001). Lung cancer patients with better insurance were correlated with aggressive surgery (rs = 0.262, p < 0.001). Similarly, surgery was also related to an extended length of stay (rs = 0.232, p < 0.001).
Distribution of outpatient and inpatient expenditures in different age groups. Influencing factors for hospitalization expenditures.
The relationship among hospitalization expenses, surgery, length of stay, insurance status, institution level, sex and age of lung cancer inpatients (rs)
| Variables | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hospitalization expenses | 1 | |||||
| 2 | Surgery | 0.481** | 1 | ||||
| 3 | Length of stay | 0.688** | 0.232** | 1 | |||
| 4 | Insurance status | 0.325** | 0.262** | 0.092** | 1 | ||
| 5 | Institution level | 0.585** | 0.542** | 0.176** | 0.375** | 1 | |
| 6 | Sex | 0.033** | -0.023* | 0.008 | -0.004 | -0.007 | 1 |
| 7 | Age | -0.041** | -0.011 | 0.003 | -0.073** | -0.085** | 0.075** |
Abbreviations: rs =Spearman's correlation coefficient. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01. Note: Surgery, insurance status, institution level and sex were coded as follows. For surgery: no surgery = 0 and surgery = 1. For insurance status (sorted by reimbursement ratio): self-funded = 1, new rural cooperative medical care or urban and rural medical insurance = 2, urban residents' basic medical insurance = 3 and urban employees' basic medical insurance = 4. For institution level: district and county hospital = 1, municipal hospital = 2 and provincial hospital = 3. For sex: female = 1 and male = 2.
Major factors that affect hospitalization expenditure
A multiple stepwise regression analysis established a regression equation. This regression equation was significant (F = 1526.550, p < 0.001) (Table 3). As the type of hospital was a 3-level unordered nominal variable, two dummy variables (GH and SH) were constructed. The correlation analyses, tolerance and variance inflation factors were included to analyze the multicollinearity among study variables and revealed weak multiple collinearity among them. From the standardized regression coefficient, the top three factors influencing logarithmic hospitalization expenditure were surgery, type of hospital and insurance status. Length of stay, institution level, and sex were also included in the regression equation. While age was excluded B = 3.094, β = 0.002, t = 0.260 and p = 0.795. All the independent variables that were incorporated into the equation accounted for 57.5% of the degree of variation in the dependent variables.
Multiple stepwise regression analysis using logarithmic hospitalization expenses of lung cancer patients as a dependent variable
| Variables | Unstandardized coefficients | Standardized coefficients | t | p-value | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B | Standard Error | β | |||
| Constant | -6669.021 | 1112.946 | -5.992 | <0.001 | |
| Type of hospital | |||||
| GH | 2449.689 | 334.497 | 0.066 | 7.323 | <0.001 |
| SH | 19612.994 | 424.750 | 0.386 | 46.175 | <0.001 |
| Length of stay | 752.051 | 11.070 | 0.473 | 67.938 | <0.001 |
| Surgery | 18262.116 | 407.652 | 0.386 | 44.798 | <0.001 |
| Insurance status | 1206.554 | 152.728 | 0.061 | 7.900 | <0.001 |
| Sex | 783.360 | 290.439 | 0.019 | 2.697 | <0.001 |
| Institution level | -572.175 | 231.621 | -0.026 | -2.470 | 0.014 |
Model fit: F = 1526.550, p < 0.001; R2 = 0.575; adjusted R2 = 0.575. Note: Two dummy variables were needed to represent the types of hospital which had three unordered levels (general hospital, traditional Chinese medicine hospital, and special hospital). They were abbreviated and constructed as follows: GH=General hospital= "1" if it was a general hospital and "0" otherwise; SH= Special hospital = "1" if it was a special hospital and "0" otherwise. As for the traditional Chinese medicine hospital, setting both GH and SH to "0" indicated it was a traditional Chinese medicine hospital.
Testing the mediational model
We conducted subsequent path analysis with structural equation modeling. The multicollinearity variables or variables independent of hospitalization costs were excluded from the subsequent mediational analyses [20]. We found a statistically significant mediating effect of surgery on the association between insurance type and hospitalization expenses. There was also a statistically significant mediating effect of length of stay on the association between surgery and hospitalization expenses. The results of the structural equation modeling are displayed in Figure 5. According to the goodness-of-fit indices [21], the measurement model provided a reasonable fit to the data (χ2 = 1.373, p = 0.241 > 0.05) (Table 4). The results of the estimated model are shown in Figure 5 and Table 5 and demonstrate the standardized path coefficients of the significant structural relationships (p < 0.05) among the tested variables. Overall, insurance status, surgery and length of stay can explain 45% of the variability in hospitalization expenses.
Fit indices for the tested model
| Item | χ2/df | GFI | AGFI | CFI | NFI | IFI | TLI | RMSEA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model value | 1.373 | 1.000 | 0.999 | 1.000 | 1.000 | 1.000 | 1.000 | 0.006 |
| Recommended value | 1<χ2/df< 3 | >0.90 | >0.90 | >0.90 | >0.90 | >0.90 | >0.90 | <0.08 |
Indirect effects of insurance type and surgery on hospitalization expenses
| Model pathways | Unstandardized coefficient | |
|---|---|---|
| Indirect effect | Total effect | |
| Insurance status→Surgery→Hospitalization expenses | 0.095 | 0.165 |
| Surgery→Length of stay→Hospitalization expenses | 0.079 | 0.457 |
Discussion
CCE of lung cancer patients
In this study, lung cancer CCE was calculated under the SHA 2011 framework. SHA 2011 was suggested to be used to produce National Health Accounts by all of the countries in the world, which makes the calculated result comparable across countries. Therefore, these results can be applied for comparisons among various countries. This study found that lung cancer accounted for a large proportion of health resources, with a total of 8063.75 million CNY in Hunan Province in 2016. When the CCE of lung cancer patients by age group were compared, the CCEs were found to be diverse between different age groups. The patients who spent the most were mainly aged 55-74 y. The CCE patterns by age closely followed the lung cancer incidence patterns. The median age at lung cancer diagnosis was approximately 70 y, with approximately 10% of cases occurring under age 55, 53% occurring between age 55-74 and 37% occurring over age 75 [22]. It is worth noting that, although the lung cancer patients aged 45-54 y did not constitute a large proportion of all lung cancer patients, their CCE was high. This result is consistent with a previous study that showed that the cost of cancer treatment is higher in younger patients than in older patients [23]. This finding may not reflect the real demand for medical resources. Younger cancer patients are more likely to seek aggressive surgery and adjuvant therapy than older patients [24]. The proportion of nontreated patients also increased with age [25]. Economic factors played a role. Younger lung cancer patients were inclined to have better economic status, and most younger patients tended to go to higher-level hospitals and use higher-priced services than older patients. Unfortunately, the high expenditure for curative treatments may be a barrier for lung cancer patients with poor economic status. Therefore, it is time to revisit the medical care needs of different lung cancer patients and develop insurance benefit programs to promote the efficient use of medical services.
Path diagram of the structural equation model.
In this study, the OOP rate in the CCE was 34.00%. This rate is close to what was reported by Chunhai T et al.: the share of OOPs accounted for 29.97% of the total health expenditure [26]. Although there is still a large gap in OOPs between China and some developed countries, the gap has narrowed. The goal of lower OOPs has already been scaled up at a national level. To improve the accessibility of medical care, the Chinese government has invested considerably and made many efforts to improve the financial protections provided by insurance. According to a report by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development and the World Health Organization, of all the countries in the Asia-Pacific region, China's out-of-pocket medical expenses have dropped the most [27].
The expenditure of each item contributed to CCE growth. Regarding the expenditure list among different hospital levels, drugs were the major driving contribution to the CCE. This finding is consistent with a previous report [28]. Chemotherapy is one of the main treatments for lung cancer [29]. New drugs have been developed to treat lung cancer, which has greatly increased the cost of treatment [30]. From this study, as the hospital level declines, the proportions of both surgery and tests also decline. For cancer patients, tumor diagnosis is an important factor for therapy choice [31]. To obtain a reliable diagnosis and undergo successful surgery, most patients intend to go to high-level hospitals.
Distribution of the CCE in medical institutions for patients with lung cancer
It is observed that much of the lung cancer patients' CCE was spent in hospitals instead of in other types of medical institutions. In terms of the CCE distributed across different levels of medical institutions, more of the CCE was spent in high-level institutions than in low-level institutions. Our study also found that the CCE varied in different hospital types, mainly in general hospitals. This finding may be because medical resources are distributed unevenly in China. The type of medical institution is closely related to its diagnostic capabilities, treatment level, medical technology, level of care, etc. With the acceleration of urbanization and the lagging supply capacity of grassroots health facilities in China, high-quality medical resources are concentrated in large hospitals, and primary medical institutions are seriously lacking in medical resources [32]. The medical facilities in grade III, class A hospitals are much better than those in other small hospitals, and people prefer to go to the relatively high-level hospitals for treatment [33]. Meanwhile, a treatment mode of “minor illness in the community, serious illness to the hospital, rehabilitation back to the community” has been established in China. Patients with severe diseases tend to go to hospitals with higher levels of treatment [34]. As cancer is considered a serious disease to every patient, patients are inclined to go to high-level and authoritative medical institutions to seek reliable therapies.
Factors influencing CCE
In total, 96.03% of the CCE for lung cancer patients was in the hospital, and 90.51% of the hospital expenditure was inpatient expenditure. Thus, a focus on the analysis of hospitalization expenses is necessary. Describe the traits of lung cancer patients' curative expenditure constitutes an essential first step in clarifying the treatment relating factors, providing data-driven evidence to key stakeholders, and achieving rationalization of the utilization of health resources for the treatment of patients. The study on the influencing factors of the CCE in China can provide a basis for the rational allocation of limited health resources. It is not only the core direction of the field of health economics but also in line with the development trend of proper individualized treatment of lung cancer. We found that the relationships between study variables and hospitalization expenses were significant, including the length of stay, surgery, type of hospital, insurance status, institution level, age and sex. Notably, these findings are in line with those of other research [35, 36].
Surgery had an inevitable effect on lung cancer patients. Surgery not only is associated with increased cost [37] but also necessitates the extension of the hospitalization duration [38]. Our findings indicated that length of stay mediated the relationship between surgery and hospitalization expense for lung cancer patients, demonstrating that the length of stay played a role in buffering the adverse effects of surgery on hospitalization expense. The length of stay is often considered a key indicator of medical resource consumption [39]. The longer the length of stay is, the more medical resources will be consumed, which induces higher hospitalization expenditures [40]. In other words, shortening the length of stay is an effective way to reduce the CCE in patients with lung cancer.
In this study, we found that insurance status is a major variable that can affect both surgery and hospitalization expenses. This finding may be attributed to several factors. For patients who have medical insurance, the medical expenditures were paid partly by the insurers, so the financial burden of lung cancer patients and their families may be relatively small. Although patients with medical insurance were prone to have a high CCE, the copay portion of the treatment costs was reduced, and the absolute quantity of expenditure was lowered, so these patients were more likely to take aggressive measures, such as surgery. The financial consequences of cancer may interfere with receiving health care services [41]. Patients with better economic conditions are more likely to pay for certain health care services [42]. Although the basic purpose of medical insurance is to apportion the economic risk of individual illness and promote fairness [43], there are still large gaps between different types of medical insurance in China. Notably, according to our survey, some lung cancer patients still have no medical insurance, and their CCE was paid entirely out of pocket. A study investigating the financial burdens of cancer patients showed that 94.2% of cancer patients at the diagnosis stage and 86.2% of cancer patients at six months after diagnosis found their financial burden to be at least somewhat difficult to handle [44]. Thus, we can surmise that the plight and financial burden of lung cancer patients without medical insurance in China are worse than those who have medical insurance. One of the core goals of universal health coverage is to avoid large individual health expenditures and catastrophic health expenditures [45]. Since 1997, the Chinese government has committed to developing social medical insurance. Recently, more efforts have been made to provide better health care [46]. However, China is a developing country with a large population, and there are still many steps required to promote health insurance coverage. Meanwhile, in this study, although the CCE of insured cancer patients was reduced by insurance, the overall ratio of OOPs for patients with lung cancer was still high, and further financial support remains necessary.
Age was negatively correlated with the hospitalization expenditure of lung cancer patients. As this association was not robust and disappeared after regression analysis, we cannot exclude the secondary effects that are attributable to the relationship of other factors. Empirical evidence suggested that the population age had only a modest effect on health expenditure growth [47]. Similarly, this study showed that age was not an important driver of the expenditure in lung cancer patients. However, in the long term, the increased longevity could gradually postpone health expenditure from one age group to the next [48].
Although previous studies have suggested the role of some factors in affecting the cost of lung cancer, no research had verified the structure-effect relationship using proper statistical models in lung cancer. On this basis, this study used the structural equation model to probe the specific influence degree and the interrelationship of these variables and achieve better explanatory efficacy. 45% of the variance of the extent of hospitalization expenses explained by the study factors. It means these factors highly determined the hospitalization expenses outcome. From this study, in addition to patient characteristics and treatment factors studied, variables more likely to improve the degree of determining hospitalization costs may be beyond the scope of this manuscript but will be worthily explored in future research. In the context of precision medicine, breakthroughs continue to be achieved in treating lung cancer. Molecular targeted therapy, immunotherapy, and stereotactic body radiation therapy were verified as better treatment strategies in certain pathological types and some disease stages of lung cancer patients [49, 50]. Therefore, in the future, we can refine the costs of different treatment methods and the types of patients, to provide more specific guidance for practice, which is also the future development trend.
Limitations should be considered in interpreting the results of the study. First, the cross-sectional nature and the “hit and miss” facet generated from random sampling of institutions might cause some selection biases. Second, most lung cancer patients are middle-aged or elderly people, and they may have other diseases at the same time. In the course of disease treatment, the cost recorded may include the treatment expense of other comorbidities besides lung cancer.
Conclusion
In summary, the application of the SHA 2011 framework promoted the way that CCE was interpreted. Under this framework, the constituent ratio of CCE, the status of insurance schemes, and financing needs can be interpreted. Health care coverage and access to health care services are still issues for lung cancer patients in China. The model used in this study provided an articulate description of the direct and mediation effects related to hospitalization expenses of lung cancer patients. When interpreting the CCE for patients with lung cancer, close attention must be paid to the contributing variables (insurance status, surgery, and length of stay) themselves and the interrelationship among them. These results highlight the need to both account for and potentially reduce the total CCE among high-incidence populations in obtaining cancer care.
Abbreviations
CCE: current curative expenditure; SHA 2011: System of Health Accounts 2011; CNY: Chinese Yuan; ICD-10: International Classification of Disease, the 10th revision; OOPs: out-of-pocket payments; GH: general hospital; SH: special hospital.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by funding from The National Natural Science of China (No. 71673299).
Competing Interests
The authors have declared that no competing interest exists.
References
1. Bray F, Ferlay J, Soerjomataram I, Siegel RL, Torre LA, Jemal A. Global cancer statistics 2018: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and mortality worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries. CA-Cancer J Clin. 2018;68:394-424
2. Cai Y, Xue M, Chen W, Hu M, Miao Z, Lan L. et al. Expenditure of hospital care on cancer in China, from 2011 to 2015. Chin J Cancer Res. 2017;29:253-62
3. Brun C, Gay P, Cottier M, Karpathiou G, Patoir A, Tiffet O. et al. Comparison of cytology, chest computed and positron emission tomography findings in malignant pleural effusion from lung cancer. J Thorac Dis. 2018;10:6903-11
4. Hirsch FR, Scagliotti GV, Mulshine JL, Kwon R, Curran WJ Jr, Wu YL. et al. Lung cancer: current therapies and new targeted treatments. Lancet. 2017;389:299-311
5. Perin J, Zarić B, Đođić JE, Potić Z, Potić M, Sekeruš V. et al. The cost of hospital treatment of advanced stage lung cancer patients in a developing South East European country. J Cancer. 2018;9:3038-45
6. Shi JF, Wang L, Wu N, Li JL, Hui ZG, Liu SM. et al. Clinical characteristics and medical service utilization of lung cancer in China, 2005-2014: Overall design and results from a multicenter retrospective epidemiologic survey. Lung cancer. 2019;128:91-100
7. Sheehan DF, Criss SD, Chen Y, Eckel A, Palazzo L, Tramontano AC. et al. Lung cancer costs by treatment strategy and phase of care among patients enrolled in Medicare. Cancer Med. 2019;8:94-103
8. Zhou LF, Zhang MX, Kong LQ, Lyman GH, Wang K, Lu W. et al. Costs, Trends, and Related Factors in Treating Lung Cancer Patients in 67 Hospitals in Guangxi, China. Cancer Invest. 2017;35:345-57
9. Xiaohua Ning, Juying Zhang. Fiscal Decentralization and Local Public Health Expenditure: Empirical Analysis Based on Different Caliber Indicators and Provincial Panel Data. Chinese Health Economics. 2018;37:16-20
10. Mueller M, Morgan D. New insights into health financing: First results of the international data collection under the System of Health Accounts 2011 framework. Health Policy. 2017;121:764-9
11. Li M, Zheng A, Duan W, Mu X, Liu C, Yang Y. et al. How to apply SHA 2011 at a subnational level in China's practical situation: take children health expenditure as an example. J Glob Health. 2018;8:010801
12. Runyan A, Banks J, Bruni DS. Current and Future Oncology Management in the United States. J Manag Care Spec Pharm. 2019;25:272-81
13. Yoon TH, Lee SY, Kim CW, Kim SY, Jeong BG, Park HK. In equalities in medical care utilization by South Korean cancer patients according to income: a retrospective cohort study. Int J Health Serv. 2011;41:51-66
14. Zhao T, Cheng J, Chai J, Feng R, Liang H, Shen X. et al. Inpatient care burden due to cancers in Anhui, China: a cross-sectional household survey. BMC Public Health. 2016;16:308
15. Yu T, He Z, Zhou Q, Ma J, Wei L. Analysis of the factors influencing lung cancer hospitalization expenses using data mining. Thorac Cancer. 2015;6:338-45
16. Xu X, Herrin J, Soulos PR, Saraf A, Roberts KB, Killelea BK. et al. The Role of Patient Factors, Cancer Characteristics, and Treatment Patterns in the Cost of Care for Medicare Beneficiaries with Breast Cancer. Health Serv Res. 2016;51:167-86
17. Song S, Yuan B, Zhang L, Cheng G, Zhu W, Hou Z. et al. Increased Inequalities in Health Resource and Access to Health Care in Rural China. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2018;16:E49
18. Chen W, Zheng R, Baade PD, Zhang S, Zeng H, Bray F. et al. Cancer statistics in China, 2015. CA Cancer J Clin. 2016;66:115-32
19. OECD Eurostat, WHO. A System of Health Accounts 2011 edition. Paris: OECD. 2011
20. Tabachnick B, Fiddell L. Using multivariate statistics. Boston, MA: Pearson. 2013
21. Wu Minglong. Structural equation modeling—the operation and application of AMOS. Chongqing: Chongqing university press. 2012
22. Howlader N, Noone AM, Krapcho M, Garshell J, Neyman N, Altekruse SF. et al. Previous Version: SEER Cancer Statistics Review. Revised 14 June 2013. 1975 -2010. https://seer.cancer.gov/archive/csr/1975_2010/
23. Hwang I, Shin DW, Kang KH, Yang HK, Kim SY, Park JH. et al. Medical Costs and Healthcare Utilization among Cancer Decedents in the Last Year of Life in 2009. Cancer Res Treat. 2016;48:365-75
24. Athas WF, Adams-Cameron M, Hunt WC, Amir-Fazli A, Key CR. Travel distance to radiation therapy and receipt of radiotherapy following breast-conserving surgery. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2000;92:269-71
25. Kim D, Kim SY, Suh B, Park JH. Trend Analysis for the Choice and Cost of Lung Cancer Treatment in South Korea, 2003-2013. Cancer Res Treat. 2018;50:757-67
26. Chunhai T, Mengying W. Analysis of influencing factors of personal health expenditure proportion in China based on Lasso regression model. Statistics & Decision. 2017;21:100-3
27. OECD and World Health Organization. Health at a Glance: Asia/Pacific 2014: Measuring Progress towards Universal Health Coverage. Paris: OECD Publishing. 2014
28. Corral J, Espinàs JA, Cots F, Pareja L, Solà J, Font R. et al. Estimation of lung cancer diagnosis and treatment costs based on a patient-level analysis in Catalonia (Spain). BMC Health Serv Res. 2015;15:70
29. Chen YF, Lin JW, Ho CC, Yang CY, Chang CH, Huang TM. et al. Outcomes of cancer therapy administered to treatment-naïve lung cancer patients in the intensive care unit. J Cancer. 2017;8:1995-2003
30. Coate LE, Leighl NB. How affordable are targeted therapies in non-small cell lung cancer?. Curr Treat Options Oncol. 2011;12:1-11
31. Del Ciello A, Franchi P, Contegiacomo A, Cicchetti G, Bonomo L, Larici AR. Missed lung cancer: when, where, and why?. Diagn Interv Radiol. 2017;23:118-26
32. Wang Y, Sun L, Hou J. Hierarchical Medical System Based on Big Data and Mobile Internet: A New Strategic Choice in Health Care. JMIR Med Inform. 2017;5:e22
33. Zhang R, Xing Y, Wang J, Shang X, Zhu X. A Novel Multiattribute Decision-Making Method Based on Point-Choquet Aggregation Operators and Its Application in Supporting the Hierarchical Medical Treatment System in China. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2018;15:E1718
34. Lan L, Cai Y, Zhang T, Wu R, Xue M, Meng Q. Influencing factors of inpatient expenditure pattern for cancer in China, 2015. Chin J Cancer Res. 2017;29:11-7
35. Huang HY, Shi JF, Guo LW, Bai YN, Liao XZ, Liu GX. et al. Expenditure and financial burden for the diagnosis and treatment of colorectal cancer in China: a hospital-based, multicenter, cross-sectional survey. Chin J Cancer. 2017;36:41
36. Mo X, Sun Z, Liu X, Shi J, Sun Z, Li M. Study on out-of-pocket expenditure and related factors among cancer inpatients with Hunan Provincial Urban Employee Basic Medical Insurance. Zhong Nan Da Xue Xue Bao (Medical Sciences). 2016;41:520-6
37. Kusachi S, Kashimura N, Konishi T, Shimizu J, Kusunoki M, Oka M. et al. Length of stay and cost for surgical site infection after abdominal and cardiac surgery in Japanese hospitals: multi-center surveillance. Surg Infect (Larchmt). 2012;13:257-65
38. Kennedy MPT, Hall PS, Callister MEJ. Secondary-care costs associated with lung cancer diagnosed at emergency hospitalisation in the United Kingdom. Thorax. 2017;72:950-952
39. Lai CI, Hung WJ, Lin LP, Chien WC, Lin JD. A retrospective population-based data analyses of inpatient care use and medical expenditure in people with intellectual disability co-occurring schizophrenia. Res Dev Disabil. 2011;32:1226-31
40. He J, Yin Z, Duan W, Wang Y, Wang X. Factors of hospitalization expenditure of the genitourinary system diseases in the aged based on "System of Health Account 2011" and neural network model. J Glob Health. 2018;8:020504
41. Nekhlyudov L, Madden J, Graves AJ, Zhang F, Soumerai SB, Ross-Degnan D. Cost-related medication nonadherence and cost-saving strategies used by elderly medicare cancer survivors. J Cancer Surviv. 2011;5:395-404
42. Lang HC. Willingness to pay for lung cancer treatment. Value Health. 2010;13:743-9
43. Wu J, Liu J, Zhu B, Mao Y. Comparative analysis on the out-of-pocket expenditure among patients suffering from chronic kidney disease between medical insurance covered and uncovered areas in China. Value Health. 2016;19:A846
44. Azzani M, Roslani AC, Su TT. Financial burden of colorectal cancer treatment among patients and their families in a middle-income country. Support Care Cancer. 2016;24:4423-32
45. Weaver KE, Rowlan JH, Bellizzi KM, Aziz NM. Forgoing medical care because of cost: Assessing disparities in healthcare access among cancer survivors living in the United States. Cancer. 2010;116:3493-504
46. Mao W, Tang S, Zhu Y, Xie Z, Chen W. Financial burden of healthcare for cancer patients with social medical insurance: a multi-centered study in urban China. Int J Equity Health. 2017;16:180
47. Nozaki M, Kashiwase K, Saito I. Health Spending in Japan: Macro-Fiscal Implications and Reform Options. Washington, DC: IMF. 2014
48. Zhai T, Goss J, Li J. Main drivers of health expenditure growth in China: a decomposition analysis. BMC Health Serv Res. 2017;17:185
49. Chai T, Zhang P, Lin Y, Zhang Z, Lin W, Kang M. et al. Postoperative adjuvant therapy for resectable early non-small cell lung cancer: A protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine. 2019;98:e16468
50. Donovan EK, Swaminath A. Stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) in the management of non-small-cell lung cancer: Clinical impact and patient perspectives. Lung Cancer. 2018;9:13-23
Author contact
Corresponding author: Xin Wang, PhD, College of the Humanities and Social Sciences, China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning, China. Tel: +86 18900911296; Email: xwang12edu.cn; Corresponding author: Liangrong Zhou, PhD, School of Humanities and Management, Hunan University of Chinese Medicine, Changsha, Hunan, China. Tel: +86 15243676288; Email: 1443361448com.
Received 2019-3-14
Accepted 2019-9-22
Published 2019-10-20
Citation styles
